Alan knows that Charlie has fucked Judith, so Charlie decides to make it better by hooking Alan up with a friend who'll be there any second. Alan isn't interested in Charlie's so-called sloppy seconds, but when he lays eyes on Haley he changes his mind. While Alan dithers, Haley walks inside and starts laying out sex toys on the couch for her MLM scheme. Alan says he doesn't know how to use any of Haley's products, so she spreads her legs and pulls her panties aside to give him a demonstration of how to use the vibrator. She offers to let Alan have a try and instructs him in its use.

When Alan scoots closer to get better instruction, Haley sees his boner and offers to take care of him. Alan agrees, and seconds later Haley has her lips and hand working together to worship Alan's big dick. She can't get enough of deep throating that hard cock, and things only get better when she turns around on her knees and hikes up her miniskirt for Alan to fuck her.

Their doggy style fuck fest continues as Haley climbs on top to ride Alan's dick. Then she falls backwards onto the couch as Alan shoves himself deep inside. Grabbing one of her toys, Haley deep throats the dildo as Alan bangs her. Then she pushes the toy inside as Alan keeps fucking her for added girth that leaves her eyes rolling back with the power of her climax. Pulling the toy out, she licks her own juices off it as she encourages Alan to cum too. He obliges, pulling out to nut all over Haley's muff.